Chapter 96 – Oops! I’m in Love with My Stepbrother Book

Well..for Neal’s sake, I hope he left the house..but sorry buddy, I know she is your daughter, but to me..she is my wife, and my wife always cums in the morning.

After getting soaked with Johnnie’s delicious juices, we ended up taking a shower and were now heading down to the kitchen.

I just had to play this cool..treat it like nothing happened..I mean, I am so used to doing whatever I want with Johnnie considering my mom is on the complete other side of the house..so yeah..having Neal here is going to be an adjustment.

“There the two love birds are.” Moose exclaimed, I was honestly surprised to see him here. He has been spending a lot of time with Milo and Anna.

But since the threat with my dad is over, he can move back into the apartment. Our place should be ready in a few days so we will just stay here until then..well, that was the plan..I don’t know about now after what happened this morning.

I walked into the kitchen just as Neal turned the corner, making me freeze in my tracks as he quickly averted his gaze.

“Um..good morning sweetheart.” He muttered, looking at Johnnie now as she left my side and gave her dad a hug. Trying not to make things even more awkward I’m sure.

But once she pulled away, Neal and I were left standing there looking away from one other as Moose looked between us curiously.

He raised his eyebrow, about to open his mouth to say something when I shoved on his chest and led him over to the kitchen island.

“Did you leave any food for us Moose?” I quipped, making him laugh as I saw the huge plates of food.

Dang, Mom went all out.

“So I was thinking we could go see a movie today, just like old times Kiddo. Ben already said he is in.” Neal spoke to Johnnie as he walked over and began making a plate for her, causing me to frown.

I was just about to make her one..I guess it’s no big deal.

“Um, sure, we don’t have any plans, right babe?” She asked me and before I could say anything, Neal interrupted.

“Oh, well..I was thinking we could just go..the three of us..like old times.” Her dad said awkwardly before rubbing the back of his neck and avoiding my gaze.

That jealousy I hated so much suddenly began to rise, making me clench my jaw before plastering a smile on my face.

“No, it’s fine..you two go, okay baby?” I said to Johnnie before walking up to her and kissing her on the head.

“Well, looks like it’s just you and me today buddy! What should we do?” Moose said cheerfully as I let out a sigh.

Why do I get the feeling that Neal doesn’t like me all of a sudden? That can’t be true..right?

(Johnnie)

I couldn’t help but stare at my dad..hearing his laughter and seeing his smile..this truly had to be a dream come true.

Ben was sitting in the front seat and Dad was driving us to the theater. I didn’t care where we went, I just wanted to be by his side.

After the awkwardness from this morning, things started to become more natural after breakfast. I said my goodbyes to Capsian as he had to practically be pulled off of me by Moose..I know he is going to miss me, but I think my dad needs some alone time with his kids.

“So, where’s that fiancee of yours? When do I get to meet her?” Dad suddenly asked Ben as he shifted in his seat slightly.

“Umm, well, we are meeting up tomorrow. Maybe afterward..” Ben explained, making my dad nod as I couldn’t help but see the worry in my brother’s eyes.

I finally got to speak to Robin the other night on the way back from dinner with Caspian’s coach. The moment she answered she started bawling her eyes out.

“Jo..what is wrong with me? Do you think Ben won’t want to be with me anymore after this?” She started, making my eyes widen as Caspian looked over at me in surprise. He could hear her crying from there and she wasn’t even on speakerphone.

“Hey, nothing is wrong with you..why do you say that?” I asked softly, trying to stay calm for her.

“I just keep freaking out..what if Ben and I end up like our parents? What if we are destined to fail before we even get to the altar?” She whispered between sniffles as I let out a sigh while turning my head and looking towards Caspian.

“I think we all have that fear Robin..but we can’t let something we had no part in decide our future..because if you believe your marriage is going to fail before it even starts..then it probably will..but..if you hold onto that spark, that reason why you fell for my brother to begin with, then you can get through this Robin. Yeah there might be fights or disagreements..but talking through them and understanding one another is where you will be different from your parents.” I said, meaning every word as I looked at my husband, knowing this just didn’t apply to Robin and Ben.

I am one lucky girl to not only have married my childhood crush but also my best friend as well..and now since getting through our challenges, we can talk through anything. We might’ve had a few bumpy years in there but now I am grateful for that time apart. Because it showed me just how miserable life can be without Caspian in it.

“Yeah..I guess you are right..” She mumbled, making me smile to myself.

“So reach out to him Robin..he misses you like crazy and I think telling him how you are feeling will really help. Ben is a great guy..you know this…and you are a great person too..” I added, which made her cry even more..she was very emotional.

I reached my hand out and squeezed my brother’s shoulder encouragingly.

“You are going to love Robin dad. She definitely adds a lot of personality to the family..and fashion sense..which we all know is much needed.” I joked, making both my dad and Ben laugh.

“Yeah..seems like you two got that from me..” He said sheepishly, making my eyes wander to his flannel shirt which Ben just so happened to be wearing one too.

I had on one of Caspian’s hoodies..per his request and a pair of skinny jeans. So I wasn’t doing much better.

Right on cue, I felt my phone vibrate as I pulled it out and saw a few texts from Caspian.

From Caspian: Miss you already..what am I supposed to do here without you?! Moose won’t stop going on about Milo and Anna..please help me.

From Caspian: P.S. Send me a picture too..preferably nude 😛

I shook my head in disbelief before glancing up and catching some type of conversation about baseball that my dad and Ben were having before snapping a quick pic of myself. Of course he asked for nudes that freaking horn dog.

To Caspian: This is all you get! and I miss you too..if you are a good boy, maybe I will let you tie me up later, then you can get your nude 😉

I responded, knowing that would get him all riled up..I know..in being cruel. But he is just so fun to tease!!

“What do you say Jojo? Want to go to our burger spot after we are done with the movie like old times?” My dad suddenly asked, making me switch my screen off before glancing up.

“Yeah sure Dad, sounds great.”

I met my dad’s eyes in the rearview mirror before smiling brightly as he cleared his throat awkwardly for a moment.

“So, you and Caspian are sticking to this marriage thing huh?” He suddenly asked out of the blue, taking me back a little.


New Book: Back Home to Marry Off Myself

Loredana’s father left the family for his mistress, leaving them to fend for themselves abroad. When life was at its toughest, her father showed up with “good news” after 8 years of absence: To marry off Loredana to a paralyzed son of the wealthy Mendelsohn family.